Lawyers For The People

Choosing between a structured settlement vs. a lump sum

On Behalf of | Oct 10, 2025 | Personal Injury

When a personal injury case ends with a large settlement or court award, the next step is deciding how to receive the funds. In New York, you have two choices: a structured settlement or a lump sum payment. Each option affects your taxes, long-term security and flexibility.

Understanding your two options

Choosing how to receive your award can feel overwhelming after a long case. Knowing the difference helps you make a confident choice.

Lump sum: You receive all your compensation at once. This gives you full control to pay off debts, invest or make big purchases immediately.

Structured settlement: You receive compensation over time through regular installments, usually funded by an annuity from an insurance company.

Each option serves different goals, so it’s important to choose what fits your financial habits and needs.

The pros and cons of a lump sum

A lump sum offers flexibility and control. You can invest the money, buy property or pay major bills right away. You decide how to use your award.

Without careful planning, on the other hand, you could overspend or make poor investments. A single payout may also affect your eligibility for benefits such as Medicaid or Supplemental Security Income (SSI). Before choosing a lump sum, work with a financial advisor to make the money last.

The pros and cons of a structured settlement

A structured settlement provides stability and predictable income. It helps you budget and prevents overspending. Additionally, payments can be customized to cover long-term needs like education or medical care.

Once set, however, the schedule is hard to change. You can’t easily access funds early, and inflation may reduce future value without a cost-of-living adjustment. If you value steady income and long-term security, this may be the safer option.

Legal considerations and final advice

Most adults can choose freely, but New York courts must approve settlements involving minors, incapacitated persons or wrongful death claims.

Before deciding, consider speaking with a financial advisor and personal injury lawyer. They may help you weigh the risks and benefits so your choice protects both your settlement and your future.

Archives

Categories